I don't understand this comment at all. No paper notebook is able to produce a log either. Just like a digital log, making a meaningful journal depends on the effort that the diver puts into it.
Why do you need paper and pen to analyze, reflect on, record or muse about your diving experience? I write MUCH more now than I ever did in a paper log book.
In addition to my own analysis and journal entries, I find it helpful to cut and paste online description of certain wrecks - that way, I have all that information right there in my log on my phone, if I revisit a site after many years. Obviously not necessary, but a nice feature.
The log could be written in electronic form on a computer. No problem there.
It is important still to reflect and write.
For me, and some other people, paper and pen have a superior accessibility. No boot times, no electricity, usable in daylight... A computer offers many benefits though so this becomes a personal preference.
I do use computer generated data (profile, average depth,...) but downloading it takes one munute while the log writing takes ten or twenty.
ps. "computer" does not sound like holiday. Cutting and pasting paper is relaxing