Crush
Contributor
The things I would stay away from are any brand new "innovative" designs.
Are you referring to Sling-Shot Fins or split fins? Probably both?
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
The things I would stay away from are any brand new "innovative" designs.
stay away from gear that is discontinued, because it will be harder to let it service.
First off, I think it's important to know that price is not a good indicator of quality. For example, the vast majority of regulators made today work well and reliably. (Manufacturers can't afford the liability of building them otherwise!) Spending a ton of money on something that is overengineered for your requirements is just wasteful. As a specific case, I bought an Aqualung Titan reg as my first regulator. It has worked well in cold and warm water, throughout the recreational range. It's still my reg. It was a good recommendation on the part of my dive shop -- they did not try to sell me their top-end reg, and I still appreciate that.
Fins are another place where I think people get badly taken -- I was. It is greatly to the dive shop's advantage to sell you the newest, slickest, highest profit-margin fins, when most people would be perfectly well served by something simpler and cheaper. I got talked into split fins with the argument that I wouldn't get cramps using them. I didn't, but you know what? I don't get them with paddle fins, either! Buy simpler, less expensive fins and use the money you save to put spring straps on them
I think simpler works fine with BCs, too. The manufacturers push their dealers to sell their highest-end product, but adding complexity to dive gear often just adds ways something can break. If you think about it, a BC just needs to do a few things: It needs to hold the tank stable on your back (many aren't very good at this); it need to contain enough air to compensate for the gas your are going to use out of your tank, and for possible loss of buoyancy from your exposure protection (and if you are diving in warm water with a thin wetsuit, this isn't much); and it needs to be comfortable to swim in -- NOT to wear around the dive shop! Bells and whistles like multiple dump valves, big pockets (which often aren't easy to use underwater) and up and down levers add cost but rarely add significant functionality.
Masks have to fit. Pay what you have to -- but evaluate the fit correctly. If you put a mask on your face and suck in to see if it will seal, they almost all will. If you put it on your face and gently press on it with your fingers, and release, a well-fitted mask will stay put, and a poor fitting one will fall immediately.
Do look through the "What did you buy that you regret?" thread. There are some definite themes there that are educational.