Hello SPthomas,
I agree with BoulderJohn. We are all different. Also, depending on the circumstance, I have been comfortable in a 5 mil custom wetsuit with hood and gloves (54F water). The day before, I needed the 5 mil jumpsuit, my 5 mil spring suit, and the hood/gloves.
It all depends on how warm I get during SI and how much good chow the dive boat served up. When I am on Peace, Specter, or a Truth boat, I eat well and don't need as much insulation. Also, I am protected from the elements because they have spacious salons. On a small boat like Double Down or Beach Hopper, I am not protected from the elements as well--on those days, I need all 10 mils that my jumpsuit and spring suit combined can give me.
As a general rule of thumb:
1) 5 mil Jump suit and 5 mil spring suit for a total of 10 mils around my body core, with water between 50F and 65F.
2) 5 mils for 65F to 75F (or my 4/3).
3) 4/3 mil jumpsuit, or spring suit for 75F to 80F.
5) 1/2 mil jumpsuit for anything above 80F.
Sometimes, I will take two wetsuits for water warmer than 65F. A warm and dry wetsuit is easier to don on that second or third dive. Stripping down to a speedo and wearing a stadium/dive jacket helps as the SI becomes a very comfortable experience--especially when you have a dry wetsuit to put on for the next dive.
markm
PS: I will never buy an "off-the-rack" wetsuit again. My custom wetsuit combo is worth every penny I paid.