Lobzilla
Contributor
I'm talking about one or two pounds. Not 9. And I might be biased by too much cold water diving, with a lot of lead to sink the dry suit - a couple pounds is just a small percentage of your total weight.
If you're two pound overweight, you'll end up with a two pound bubble in your BC. Even if you forget to purge from 30ft to 10ft, you'll end up at +3lbs at 10 ft, which isn't enough (by far) to send you in an uncontrolled ascent, and can be fixed easily.
If you're two pound underweight, you'll have to do your whole safety stop at +2lbs. Which means constantly kicking or holding to an anchor line/kelp frond/rock. Not fun, and potentially dangerous if an earlier incident causes you to come back below 500psi or you're assisting another diver.
Grossly overweight is no fun either, but if I'm not sure about my exact weighting I'd rather shove one more pound in a pocket and ditch it for the next dive than risk struggling for the whole end of a dive.
Thanks for explaning. So, an easy way to get in the ballpark with unfamiliar tanks/equipment would be to have enough weight to hover just below the sfc with dumped BC and suit, then add 8lbs of lead for every 100cuft of air you carry and another 1 - 2 lbs for safety?