No more spearfishing in south Florida?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

@buckled plates
I'm pro spear fishing, I'm just against spearfishing some species like Goliath Groupers. I'm for sustainable use of resources so that people still can go spearfishing in 50 years. How you get from this to 'shaddowy forces', I don't get.

@CuzzA
The level of ignorance in each and every paragraph of your post is shocking. Don't let the lizard people get you and have fun in fantasy land. You're invoking the Nazis in a thread about spearfishing regulations... must I say more.

One thing I will comment on though:
You must not understand how the USA became the super power it is today.
Sure I know, the US became a super power because of great and SMART people not because of people in tinfoil hats and theories about lizard people.
 
@buckled plates
I'm pro spear fishing, I'm just against spearfishing some species like Goliath Groupers. I'm for sustainable use of resources so that people still can go spearfishing in 50 years. How you get from this to 'shaddowy forces', I don't get.

@CuzzA
The level of ignorance in each and every paragraph of your post is shocking. Don't let the lizard people get you and have fun in fantasy land. You're invoking the Nazis in a thread about spearfishing regulations... must I say more.

One thing I will comment on though:

Sure I know, the US became a super power because of great and SMART people not because of people in tinfoil hats and theories about lizard people.

Oh Bennno... Lizard people, tinfoil hats, ignorance? Look, I forgive you for doing what most people do when they are corrected or don't have a solid rebuttal in a debate or discussion... They resort to personal attacks. I understand it and am all too familiar with it. Earlier you employed the Fox News trick. Haha. You gotta pick a new one, that's been so over used it doesn't work anymore.

The topic of the thread shifted from proposed government regulations pertaining to scuba diving, as pointed out earlier, this isn't just about spearfishing (read the proposals), to government and who's behind all of this. Do some research on what buckled plates posted about who Pastor Martin Niemoller is and you'll see why I mentioned Germany. I was being slightly facetious. But still, I think you have completely missed the point. You are extremely naive if you don't believe people in government eventually become corrupted by power, control and money.

And just so you know. Jewfish have been protected since 1990. No one is spearfishing them. However, some would argue their populations are doing so well now and since they consume so many other important reef fish, including sharks, we should start harvesting them like we do alligators and now bears in the state of Florida. By issuing tags to hunters.
 
...or don't have a solid rebuttal in a debate or discussion...
No, I don't rebutt your statements for the same reason I wont discuss people that believe aliens have landed near Area 51, we're really living in the Matrix or that the 'jury is still out on evolution'. You don't have anything to base your theories on, you just make stuff up.
I tried to explain to you that AI has been around since 95 without any changes. You didn't even get that that's not new tech and now you wanna talk economics with me?

...and who's behind all of this.
Pfffff, yeah right dude, the Illuminate trying to get spearfishing banned... makes sense.
 
No, I don't rebutt your statements for the same reason I wont discuss people that believe aliens have landed near Area 51, we're really living in the Matrix or that the 'jury is still out on evolution'. You don't have anything to base your theories on, you just make stuff up.
I tried to explain to you that AI has been around since 95 without any changes. You didn't even get that that's not new tech and now you wanna talk economics with me?


Pfffff, yeah right dude, the Illuminate trying to get spearfishing banned... makes sense.

Here Bennno. I'll make this easier for you. I can only lead a horse to water. These are not theories. This is what happened. While this wasn't the only issues surrounding the recent financial crisis, it most certainly was the trigger. NOT, because there was a lack of regulation as you put it.

The Government Did It

Here's How The Community Reinvestment Act Led To The Housing Bubble's Lax Lending

And here's some info to read about Jewfish.

Goliath Grouper/Jewfish (Epinephelus itajara) - Southeast Fisheries Science Center : NOAA : National Marine Fisheries Service

By the way. Nazi is short for National Socialism. While not the exact same as the democratic socialism ideology, they are close and it's still terrible compared to capitalism. Not to mention, once implemented, democratic socialism could easily change to national socialism depending on who has power.

As far as AI, I pointed out I was not involved in the sport when it became available and provided information from Sunnto's website. Unlike you, once others made me aware of the information, I gladly accepted the new information and did not try to pound the table to force my thoughts.
 
Nazi is short for National Socialism. While not the exact same as the democratic socialism ideology, they are close and it's still terrible compared to capitalism.
Ok, can you really be this dumb??? National socialism is close to democratic socialism? You obviously don't know what either of those thinks mean.
I will tell you this and then I'm done, I will not further engage in this rediculous argument.
The Nazis called themselves national socialists, that doesn't mean they were socialists. North Korea calls itself 'Democratic Rebublic'. How democratic do you think is North Korea, Cuzza? Huh? Here is a hint, dictators lie. North Korea is NOT a democratic country and the nazis were NOT socialists. It's called propaganda.
I hope you understand that North Korea is not a democracy.
See, that's want I meant when I said it's pointless to discuss your theories.
 
I thought it was common sense that selectively killing the biggest, healthiest fish on a reef is BAD given you are taking out the best breeding stock. I think undercurrent last month had a article that an illegal spearfisher took out all of a certain species on a reef a few months back. One man's selfishness destroys the enjoyment of thousands.
 
Ok, can you really be this dumb??? National socialism is close to democratic socialism? You obviously don't know what either of those thinks mean.
I will tell you this and then I'm done, I will not further engage in this rediculous argument.
The Nazis called themselves national socialists, that doesn't mean they were socialists. North Korea calls itself 'Democratic Rebublic'. How democratic do you think is North Korea, Cuzza? Huh? Here is a hint, dictators lie. North Korea is NOT a democratic country and the nazis were NOT socialists. It's called propaganda.
I hope you understand that North Korea is not a democracy.
See, that's want I meant when I said it's pointless to discuss your theories.

Here's some more water Bennno, from another horse's mouth. lol. 10 Similarities and Differences of National and Democratic Socialism

Before calling someone dumb, (which I take no offense to by the way, you only bolster my argument to the reader), just stop for a second and really think about your responses in this thread. :wink: Nevertheless, I agree with you, let's just wrap up our interaction and keep it that way. Good luck with the socialism in Europe, I truly hope the people over there don't have to continue to suffer in places like Greece. But, you know what they say about the definition of insanity. :)
 
I thought it was common sense that selectively killing the biggest, healthiest fish on a reef is BAD given you are taking out the best breeding stock. I think undercurrent last month had a article that an illegal spearfisher took out all of a certain species on a reef a few months back. One man's selfishness destroys the enjoyment of thousands.

@mikeycanuk I don't think anyone would disagree with that. I think you should post the link you're referring too, but from your post the operative word is "illegal spearfisher". A law or regulation obviously didn't change what supposedly happened.

I can't speak for other sportsmen, but I practice sustainability. I don't try to limit out just because the law says I can take X amount of fish. I don't clean out a ledge. I don't liter, in fact I pick up litter when I'm on the water. Tires, balloons, beer cans, you name it. I think you'll find most true sportsmen are far more conservationist and practice sustainability than they get credit for.
 
Back to the subject of the thread:

So here we have a prima facie case of a Non-Government Organization (NGO) operating behind the scenes and agitating through a labyrinth of organizations that few have ever heard about: "Our Florida Reefs," hosted by the "Southeast Florida Reef Initiative" (SEFRI), working through "Community Working Groups," and the "Florida Coral Reef Conservation Program," and funded through the "Coral Reef Conservation Program" (CRCP) of the NOAA and "Florida Department of Environmental Protection" with additional in-kind support provided by the many (my italics, not theirs) partner agencies and organizations that comprise SEFRI...in the absence if any public consensus, outcry for change, or even a long and public debate, working to bring about a rule that would forever end spearfishing while scuba diving in Southeast Florida.

On top of that, the only reason any of us knows about this is because we were alerted by a news story and prompt by DEMA.

Shadowy organizations? I'll let the reader decide who's paranoid, or who's deluded.

As for who these people are? No, they're not "illuminate." But they are bien pensants, the "right thinkers," the "do gooders," the people who believe by right of their education, position, and status, that they know better than we do:

http://ourfloridareefs.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/CWG-Yearbook_updated-1.28.16.pdf
 
From a horses mouth? This is were you get your info from? The 10 point on the website are a joke. Most of the stuff they claim is not even true and I could prove it to you. But you would have to read more than 10 points on a website.
Do yourself a favor and buy a book instead of reading website like these. if you really get your info from site like this, I feel sorry for you.

Greece is not broke because of democratic socialism. But hey, that's just a fact, so why would you care.
Good luck with our socialism? Canada has democratic socialism too and they have a higher standard of living than the US.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/
https://xf2.scubaboard.com/community/forums/cave-diving.45/

Back
Top Bottom