Teen paralyzed diving in the Keys - anyone have more info?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

From the college's FB page:
Coach John Ross Matt DeVlieger - Please lift up student Matthew DeVlieger in prayer as he recently
suffered a serious scuba diving accident while on vacation in the keys Monday morning. He is in critical care and is currently paralised from the chest down. He has little strength and breathing is often difficult. Pray for strength an...d a quick recovery. Also please pray for the DeVlieger family as they handle this difficult situation. More
will be known soon.



Wed at 1:18pm
Calvin College Thanks Coach Ross. Many, many people will be praying for Matt now and in the coming days. And praying for you as his coach and for Matt's fellow men's tennis players at Calvin.

Thu at 7:25pm


Calvin College Matt's situation remains unchanged. His days now include decompression treatment, physical therapy and awaiting test results. Matt has been accepted by a specialist at the University of Miami Hospital and will be (or already has) been transferred from Mariner hospital in the Keys to Miami. Matthew and his family continue to wait, eager to see progress and thankful for the answered prayer of providing the specialist in Miami.

6 hours ago


Julie Rainey-Hiatt Matthew's Address "Cards Only"

Matthew DeVlieger
Jackson Memorial Hospital
Neuroscience Intensive Care Unit
West Wing #851
1611 Northwest 12th Avenue
Miami, FL 33136-1096

4 hours ago · Report
 
Since Calvin College is pretty local to us we were trying to find out more information too. Here is the only follow-up article I could locate:

Calvin student paralyzed in diving accident 'optimistic' about recovery
By Nardy Baeza Bickel | The Grand Rapids Pr...
January 08, 2010, 6:49AM

Matthew DeVlieger scuba diveOK.jpgCourtesy PhotoCalvin College biology major Matthew DeVlieger, 21, on a previous scuba diving trip at the Florida Keys. He was partially paralyzed last month in a scuba diving accident.For Matthew DeVlieger, a Christmas break dive in the Gulf of Mexico became a lesson in mortality.

As he and his twin brother Andrew watched schools of fish while swimming near the sunken U.S.S. Spiegel Grove about 135 feet deep, Matthew came to the grim realization he was short oxygen.

"I was thinking I needed to get to get to the surface; that I didn't want to run out of air," he said Thursday by telephone from a Miami hospital. "I just needed to get out."

The next few minutes were critical for the 21-year-old Calvin College junior. While he survived the Dec. 28 incident after suffering decompression sickness, he now faces rehabilitation and questions whether he'll walk again.

Matthew DEVLIEGER.jpgMatthew DeVlieger"I'm optimistic," DeVlieger said. "I know it's going to be a lot of hard work and rehabilitation. I'm ready for it."

He recovered enough to be moved out of Jackson Memorial Hospital's neuroscience intensive-care unit and hopes are he can soon be transferred to a rehabilitation hospital.

A Calvin men's tennis player like his brother, Matthew has regained mobility in his right arm and has seen improvements in his left hand. A feeding tube has been removed; on Wednesday, he had lunch from Taco Bell.

"It was pretty tasty, but I'm not sure if it settled that well," he joked.

His positive attitude and faith have helped, said his mother, Sandie DeVlieger.

"There's a joy in his face and a light in his eyes," she said. "He's so accepting of what the Lord will have him do. It's pretty amazing."

His father, Robert, who was on the dive with the twins, has returned to Grand Rapids to work. His sister Denise Teitsma also has been at his side.

For Matthew, scuba diving has been a pursuit for nearly six years. Besides diving off Florida's Keys at Jules Undersea Lodge near Key Largo, he also had dived off Australia's Great Barrier Reef.

For his latest dive, he wanted an up-close look of the U.S.S. Spiegel, a 510-foot-long U.S. Navy ship decommissioned after 33 years of service in 1989 and sunk as an artificial reef in May 2002.

After Robert surfaced with his smaller air tank, Matthew and Andrew were still in the Gulf's depths when reality set.

"I told my brother I had to go," Matthew said. "I tried to ascend slowly, at a small angle. But as I finned, the air in my vest expanded. That drew me up quicker than I expected."

His brother knew something was amiss.

"He was going pretty fast; not making the stops," Andrew said.

An ascent that should have taken 20 minutes only took about five.

On the surface, Matthew swam to the boat and started taking off his swim fins.

"I started noticing there was something wrong," he said. "I needed to gasp for air. There was a tingling on my chest, torso area. I got on the boat, and it took a while, but I lost sensation in my legs."

The U.S. Coast Guard was called, and an ambulance met them at the pier.

A biology major, Matthew knew what happened. He suffered the bends, which occurs when an ascent is too quick. Nitrogen bubbles form in the bloodstream and tissue, a sickness caused because the surrounding pressure is much lower.

In his case, nitrogen bubbles formed in his spine, partially paralyzing him.

"Everything from the chest down is pretty numb," Matthew said.

But he remains optimistic along with his family, who are grateful for prayers and letters of support received from across the country.

"God works in mysterious ways, and it's hard to see that now," Andrew said. "But we have total faith and confidence in God, and we're taking it one day at the time. ... We're praying for a miracle."

Sorry I can't post URLs yet.
 
good luck to him.

I would post more but everyone would just get mad at me and I'd get banned.
 
Sounds like he got low on air, got scared, lost control of his buoyancy and blew off a mandatory 20 minutes deco? But who really knows with the newspaper story.

I wonder if he was carrying a pony bottle, and if he had one to use, would he be playing tennis now? Very sad.
 
Edited because after some reading I realize I do not know what the heck I am talking about and need more training in Deepstops and Deco diving.
 
Last edited:
This last article, in my mind, raises more questions than it answers, assuming the 20 minute ascent requirement is correct. (Big assumption.) In fact, little of this makes sense with that statement included.

If he owed 20 minutes of deco and his brother was with him, did the brother do 20 minutes of deco? If so, why did the brother have 20 minutes more gas?

How did they know they needed 20 minutes of deco? Usually people who know they need that much deco would have the training necessary to deal with expanding air in the BCD, and they would know a lot more about decompression procedures than this story indicates.

"He was going pretty fast; not making the stops," Andrew said.

This sentence indicates that they were expecting to do multiple stops, which is consistent with a 20 minute deco obligation. Again, though, this implies a level of training and planning (and gas resources) that seems to totally contradict everything else in the story.
 
A couple of things don't make sense, however, I imagine that's based on lack of more information:

1- There are several mooring lines on the Spiegel Grove... was Matthew in free ascent?
2- One of the reports detailed he had six years diving experience... venting the wing on ascent became 2nd nature years before I'd been diving six years -- was there any indication of how many dives he'd done in those six years?
3- There was an indication they were diving at 135 feet... why? That's the sandy bottom at the Grove, with basically nothing to see (been there, done that). The deck is between 80-90 feet. (I realize you can easily accumulate a deco obligation at 90 feet, however, 130 adds more than an atmosphere).
4- Obvious question... his buddy?

We certainly hope Matthew makes a full recovery. The questions are simply to better understand the what and why, so as to continually tweak and improve our own practices...
 
First and foremost two things I want to put forward as it pertains to any accidents of divers here.

As a LEO we pick apart every LEO death and point out every error MMQB to the tenth degree. We like to do this for two reasons. Number one for training purposes so that scenario and those mistakes will never cost another life. Number Two the unsaid reason we like to say.."Well there is were he screwed up... THAT would NEVER happen to me." It makes us feel better thinking that when it may be true THAT might not get us but any of us could throw snake eyes on any given dive.

I think the reporter just typed up what he heard.

I speculate the 20 ascent is somebody's bejumbled math of a NDL ascent with deepstops added and a five minute SS. I can not keep up with the kewl kids science these days I think they are at like 3 minutes at half then a couple 1 minute stops then a 5 min SS still not :20 though.

Six years diving does not mean 2,190 dives (365x6). Guessing he is a vacation diver and just jumped in. The Speigel is very dangerous in my opinion. It is deeper than many Vacationeers go. The current can get ripping. IT IS so huge you can get mezmorized and forget to make your checks. EVERYONE is Narc'd over 100' some are just better drunks than others. It is a destination vacation divers go to without creeping up to it with dives at 80-90-100-110-120-130. This is not to mention the massive interior that is a WHOLE nother box of pandora's.

So like the Law Enforcment community hopefully this will be an example that makes at least ONE person train a bit more before jumping in over their head.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/
https://xf2.scubaboard.com/community/forums/cave-diving.45/

Back
Top Bottom