My Dilemma - Wakatobi/Bali or North Sulawesi??

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Philip, I can recommend Santika Hotel as a Bunaken mainland option. It is probably a 3.5 star hotel and has a very nice pool area. Thalassa Dive, an excellent dive op, operate from the hotel grounds and the great thing is that it is located directly opposite Bunaken Island so the boat trips are only 10 mins. Check it out.

I concur with some of the others, I also recommend you include Bangka Is in your itinerary.
 
My 2 cents. I am going solo to Sulawesi next spring. Having planned, 2 weeks in North Sulawesi, I chose to stay in Bangka and Bunaken. Not Lembeth for me, I am too much a coral fan !
Also I prefer to stay on the islands rather than in Manado on mainland. Not sure that there is much to do there. For what I like to do after diving (lazing around, discussing about diving, staring at palm trees, etc), I find it is better to stay at your dive center.
 
Lee, thanks for advice- will probably end up on island in the end after all.
 
Hi

I stayed with Roel and his team at Lumbalumba 2 years ago while I was solo travelling around North Sulawesi diving and they were FANTASTIC !!! Because there are only 4 cottages - the care and attention you get is unsurpassed. I also stayed with Murex, Siladen Resort, Lembeh Resort and Ganngga Resort and Lumba Lumba was heaps better value than these others and a much better proposition all around in terms of the professionalism of the dive outfit and the quality of accommodation and yummmy food - but best of all was their helpful friendliness to me as a solo diver. Highly recommended.

cheers
sisterfin
 
Wakatobi if you think it is your one and only trip to Indo. We lived in Indo for 10 years. I love Bunaken and have been many times but Wakatobi is the best diving I have ever done and worth the money.
 
There were a number of negative comments about Wakatobi in this thread. The first I have ever read anywhere. I was planning on going there but after reading these negative comments and the great expense of getting there I am having second thoughts. Can you expand on your statement regarding it being the best in Indonesia if its your only visit there. I've been to palau,Cocos,Thailand, etc. so I've experienced great diving.
Thanks
 
There were a number of negative comments about Wakatobi in this thread. The first I have ever read anywhere. I was planning on going there but after reading these negative comments and the great expense of getting there I am having second thoughts. Can you expand on your statement regarding it being the best in Indonesia if its your only visit there. I've been to palau,Cocos,Thailand, etc. so I've experienced great diving.
Thanks

Wakatobi is not the finest diving in Indonesia. When I was there (October) IF I would of had an 30' additional vis and the water would of been 3 to 5 degrees warmer I would of enjoyed it much more. But it still would not of been the finest diving in Indonesia. Perhaps the best value diving for the buck as you can dive 1 or 5 times a day for the same price and an excellent operation. The best spots I have dove in Indonesia are as follows.

1. Papua....This beats Palau...massive schools of fish, muck diving etc etc...not much in the way of Sharks though.
2. Lembeh...finest for Muck diving weird stuff and I am not a muck diver...I loved it!
3. East Timor....untouched reefs lots of marine life
4. Bali....under rated diving very good
5. Wakatobi....when I was there for 10 days in October 30' vis water temps 77 to 80 degrees....not much that I could see in Marine life just Pigmy seahorses and some nudis!

Do the Lembeh and Papua areas it is the finest diving I have ever seen....and I am a Palau diver...I've been there 8 times.
 
We split a trip between Lembeh and Bunaken last year. Next time, we will not be returning to Bunaken. Lembeh had tons of UW oddballs, tons of sites and no current. Bunaken had nice fish, lots of sites, but major current on virtually all of our dives.

Most resorts at Lembeh will do a day trip to Bangka.
 
Bunaken currents - are highly variable. You should expect current on Bunaken, that said, on our visit last year we had virtually none. Much depends on the moon etc. This also has effects on what you see - but that is true of most destinations. The currents take you along the wall and it is an exhilerating tour of the magnificent fans, crinoids, reef fish, bigger things like black-tips, all sorts of jacks, turtles and Napoleon wrasse etc etc.

The point which seems to be overlooked here is that there is superb critter diving on the Manado side, which is also warmer than Lembeh and not subject to the currents that Bunaken sees. So staying on the Manado side gives Bunaken's walls and drift dives as well as critter diving on the Manado side. It is perfectly feasible to drive over to Lembeh and spend some time there. Lembeh is undoubtedly the best muck-diving. Another advantage of Manado is the oportunity for non-diving activites such as climbing volcanoes, visiting Tangkoko National Park for land-based critters like tarsiers, taking a tour of the highland areas and seeing the market in Tomohon. Manado itself is a typical noisy, dusty Indonesian town but if you are in Indonesia you might want to see what that is like - and it is easy to walk around, you will not get hassled on the streets.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/

Back
Top Bottom