How many have legitimately used your knife/shears underwater in an emergency?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

On one occasion ( out of over 500 dives) I used my 3 inch blunt point slip-in-my- bcd knife to free a student diver from entanglement in a float line for a crawdad trap in a local reservoir. That's it for me.
DivemasterDennis
 
Last edited:
How many of you have legitimately had to use your knife or shears in an emergency or entanglement situation?

Only one time. During a training tech dive in Gilboa Quarry, Ohio (USA), c. 1995. Both my buddy and I were in drysuit and doubles (and, maybe, a single deco bottle). We were practicing deploying DSMB's (actually, ~50# open-ended lift bags) attached to cave reels with wreck line. IIRC, depth was ~50 ffw. My buddy used her primary to fill her lift bag while I observed, facing her. Somehow, her wreck line ensnared some part of her gear, and her bag began dragging her to the surface as it ascended.

Those days I carried my small, very sharp Wenoka rec diving knife ("Blackie Collins" stiletto) on my inside calf. In a quick moment I was able to draw the knife and slice the wreck line which freed her and allowed her bag to accelerate to the surface without her.

Scary moment. Well, the actual moment wasn't scary, as I reacted without thinking. It was only later when contemplating the moment did things become scary to me.

What did I learn? Well, I had noticed the couple of feet of free-floating wreck line that she had spooled off her reel just before she began inflating her lift bag. However, I didn't watch to make sure this billowing line didn't snare her gear.

Safe Diving,

Ronald
 
Once, entering at a dock - buddy picked up a line on a fin - subsequent finning to get disentangled was causing the vis to get really really bad. Not really an emergency, but cutting was easier than trying to unwind.
 
What Knife/ Shears? Do not own either, in 39 years have never needed.
 
A more relevant question might be: have you ever been entangled whilst not carrying a cutting tool?

Of course there might be a few people who are sadly not here to give us their reflections on that.
 
On my first dive outing after being certified I got tangle in fishing line. and I decided I wanted a cut tool after that. So I now carry one with me. I hope I never seriously need it, but I also hope I never seriously need my alt. air either.
 
I have had to use a dive knife for killing a jellyfish that entangled its stingers in my arm and gave a me a nasty sting. That was only half of it, the rest was getting the damn thing off of me as it continued stinging me after it was killed
 
Dangerous and scary! I saw the crab pot rope just in time to think, "I hope it doesn't get wrapped around my yoke" - it did. I thought, great, now I''ll have do all those maneuvers to get out of my BC ... But no - I pulled my big knife out and sawed through the rope and untangled myself. I then tied the rope back together and and went on my way. Usually with fishing line I'm able to grab and break it, but if not - I cut it with my large knife or with my surgical shears.
 
I am always finding fishing lines or driftnets on the reefs here. I do not use or take a knife, because you have to have tension on the line to cut it and/or you end up with a nick here or there, always, it seems. My EMT shears. Those are the best. They cut through anthing like butter, with no tension needed on the line.
Even with students, I will cut the lines. The students like helping follow the line and rolling it up. they also get to practice buoyancy skills and movement.

One time, there was a large monofilament driftnet fouled around a buoy at one of the reefs. Corks had some of it floating, but it was draped and wrapped all the way to the bottom of the line too. My DM and I hopped in and swam over to clear it. so the boat could come in. He had just been telling us how much better his knife was than my little scissors. As we swam over, I told him we should start from the bottom and roll it up as we go. He said no. He was starting at the top. Okay. Learn from your mistakes....
I was cutting away and rolling it up, when I saw a shape plummet down beside me. He was wrapped completely in the net, had pulled off his bc, was riding it down, and wrapping himself up even more. You know, current pulls the floaty bits and he was just hacking at it, since he couldn't roll it with one hand and cut with the other, and it wrapped around him.

I grabbed him, cut him free, waited for him to put his gear back on, then pointed at the bottom of the net. He stayed with me and we finished in about ten more minutes. Huge net then smelling up the boat, and one sheepish dm who learned a lesson about clearing line and nets. He now carries scissors. The emt shears cut through anything.
 
..snip..
The emt shears cut through anything.

Except a rope tightly wrapped around a prop shaft and locked in hard. :wink:
 

Back
Top Bottom