Pauly854
Contributor
Personally, I have no problem if someone wants to dive with a DM. If it makes you feel more comfortable, knock yourself out. I think the problem with the original thread that you referenced, and the issues that most of those commenting had a problem with, are that the divers in question were totally relying on the DM to protect them. I'm sorry, but that is ridiculous. They can provide a valuble service showing the sights, best entry/exit, being a buddy to a solo...but you cannot rely on them to keep you safe! The original thread suggested that they "should lose their license" because the DM didn't "check our air pressure". If you agree that someone else should keep tabs on your air for you, then there is a serious problem. Bottom line: A DM should be nothing more than a very good dive buddy. Someone to dive with that knows what they are doing, is experienced, and can help you if you need it. The same things you should look for in a non-professional dive buddy. That is my humble 2 cents.