How safe do you feel when you dive?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

ADA_JIM

Registered
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Location
Cageside
# of dives
25 - 49
Safety is obviously a big concern for all of us when we dive but how ho safe do you guys actually feel when you go diving?

1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?
 
1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?
My safety is paramount when I dive

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?
Yes & yes if I'm unable to

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?
Usually after a dive do I go over whether or not I can make it safer next time

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?
It depends on the tech. Usually new tech brings a high premium that's always outside my budget

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?

Not at this time as I'm just thinking of my next dive :)
 
Last edited:
Diving include a certain level of risk anyway, so I do my best to make it as safety as possible. I dive within my limits, I plan all my dives - even for the "guided" ones I build a plan based on the information provided by DM or guide - and I planned them as I would be a solo diver. I'm a good buddy (at least this is what the others are saying when they dive with me) but I don't count on others in case of something bad will happen . I rather prefer to be ready to help myself. So I took and taking as much training as possible, I play the "if game", imagine different difficult situation and the solution for them and ever is possible performing different skills underwater (with or without my buddy).
Regarding a new technology which could bring a plus of safety..., I don't know. I think I would ask first a lot of information to be certain about that and only than...
And for your point 5... hm, an additional brain, to think faster and better? :giggle:
 
1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?

YES, on every dive. A significant part of my dive planning involves risk assessment, and pre-emptive risk mitigation.

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?

I take care of myself.

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?

I think about it before and during every dive.

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?

Possibly, not necessarily. It is a trade-off, between perception of actual improvement in safety, and 'burden' of using it - cost, availability, etc. For example, I dive in the ocean, a lot, and I do not carry an EPIRB, or dye marker. Of course, I only go out with operators that I know, and am comfortable with. Others may make a different choice.

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?


Sure, a completely enclosed 'bubble' that would prevent issues with air supply, marine life injuries, temperature deviations, etc., which would protect me from depth-associated injuries if I were caught in a severe down current, or had a loss of buoyancy, and would protect me if I was pulled away from the boat / shore by a current - something like the lifeboats on some ships today.

Of course, I wouldn't use one, because it would make diving prohibitively expensive, and completely pointless.
 
I suspect there is ambiguity in the first sentence because the word "concern" can be interpreted two ways. Being concerned about something can mean that it is important to you, so you take appropriate measures. Because you take those measures, you don't feel any worry about it. That would describe me. It can also mean that you are worried--feel a level of fear--about your safety when you dive, but you dive anyway. I suspect this second meaning is what the OP intended.

Interestingly enough, I heard a conversation related to that on a boat recently. Two older gentlemen were talking between dives. Both were obviously highly experienced, highly skilled divers. One of them was saying that he always feels a little afraid when he gets into the water. The other said, "I always get a little afraid when you get into the water, too."
 
1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?

Yes we go through what to do in an emergency and what dangers are present at each site

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?
I take care of myself and am prepared to respond to a buddy if he/she is in need
3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?
This is part of pre/post dive talks

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?

Depends on what it is

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?
Unfortunately nope
 
I need the help of ScubaBoard to develop a new safety device

that would be this....

1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?

obviously

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?

myself, unless I am in a teaching scenario, but by the time students reach OW, they must rely on themselves, I am in the background during all but the first of their dives

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?

before and after every dive

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?

it depends, safety at this point is limited to the living technology between your ears. Dive gear is much safer than it used to be, although rebreathers could still use some work

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?


no
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?
Safety is ALWAYS the first priority

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?
My safety is first and foremost my responsibility. I dive with buddies that i know to be safe divers and capable of assisting in the event of an emergency

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?
Often. Training and skills practice is the best path to safer diving

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?
Maybe. Relying on technology is too often a crutch. My dive computer is the first safety measure after skills and training. a fallback safety technology is my Nautilus Lifeline device.

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?

not specifically at this time. i'm seeing new advances in dive computers that may add to safety.
 
Safety is obviously a big concern for all of us when we dive but how ho safe do you guys actually feel when you go diving?
Safety should be a concern no matter what you do in life. On the other hand, there's such a thing as overdoing it, which can then become counterproductive in that it can defeat the whole point of the activity in question.

1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?
It depends on what you mean by "big concern". Diving comes with certain risks. Some are predictable, others are not. A big part of "safety" involves preparing for the predictable risks and making sure you have the skills and knowledge to deal with the unpredictable ones if something should go wrong during the dive. But an equally big part of "safety" involves using good judgment ... deciding when conditions make the dive not worth doing ... knowing and staying within the limits of your training, experience, skill level, and equipment. These are not concerns so much as they are simply developing good diving habits.

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?
Never ... ever ... rely on someone else to keep you safe. Dive guides aren't there to take care of your safety ... they're there to guide you through a dive you're unfamiliar with, and to point out critters you might not otherwise see or recognize as the things you came to see. Your safety is strictly your responsibility.

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?
Constantly ... particularly when diving at an unfamiliar site or putting myself into a new environment. That's why I think about appropriate training for the type of diving I want to do, and why I'm always conscious of the human tendency to think ourselves more skilled at pretty much everything than we actually are. Most of what I do to "make myself safer" involves my mental approach to diving, which falls into the categories of (a) planning, (b) preparedness, and (c) awareness.


4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?
It depends on the technology. If it's technology that makes the equipment more robust or reliable, then I certainly would. But most advances in dive gear would fall into the category of convenience features, and wouldn't necessarily make me feel any safer. Many convenience features can actually make you less safe by giving you a false sense of security, or by making it easier for you to grow dependent on using technology when you should be using your brain to keep you safe.


5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?
Again it depends on what you mean. We rely on technology to keep us safe whilst diving at all levels. But technology is only tools, and your safety is less about the tools you have than it is about how you use them.

... Bob (Grateful Diver)
 
Safety is obviously a big concern for all of us when we dive but how ho safe do you guys actually feel when you go diving?

1. Is safety a big concern to you when you go diving?

2. Do you take care of your own safety or do you rely on others to guide you?

3. Have you ever thought about how you could make yourself safer when going diving?

4. If a new technology was available that could make you safer would you use it?

5. Can you think of a technology that could make you feel safer whilst diving?

You may find a tough audience on SB. If there is one idea that is pervasive on SB that I have thoroughly bought into, it's the idea that technology is not the first place to look for improving diving safety. The first place to look is toward oneself: training, experience, knowing one's limits, improving one's skills. The proposed technology you posted about in that other thread--a sort of buddy monitor--seems intended to compensate for a lack of situational awareness. Improving my and my buddy's situational awareness would come first, before I looked to technology for help. Of course, if there were some sort of monitor that was inexpensive and had sufficient range, it could supplement our skills. But then again, I wonder if there would not be an issue with people developing a false sense of security--relying on this monitor instead of, not in addition to, improving their situational awareness.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/teric/

Back
Top Bottom