For their sake, I hope a bunch of these "experts" who are diving unproven methods by the seat of their pants have good insurance coverage.
Sooner or later it will catch up with them I am sure.
Dive tables or computer. To do it on instinct alone is like Russian roulette, sooner of later something for sure will go boom.
computers today are cheap, cheaper than in many cases of buying a watch and depth gauge. So why not dive with one? I can see no need with a computer on 20-30ft dives, but anything else you are losing out on additional bottom time and increased factor of safety. Too many people forget how to use a simple rdp. One asst instr here stated he hated using it for DM. For DM course it's use should be second nature, using either version, RDP or eRDPml,which is required To be owned during a DM course. The eRDPml and rdp is included in DM learning materials.
Only takes a few seconds,maybe less than 10 seconds to plan out a dive with a surface interval and a repetitive dive,with either version, but you have to now monitor your depth and time carefully.
Use a computer and if you forget some of its functions it will still likely tell you go up.