Thanks guys,
Sounds like I was on the right track with Casa Mexicana. If I end up back in Cozumel this spring I will probably just book there as it's within my budget for the room. I had considering Blue Angel Resort as well and switching up my dive op but I think it would be about the same issue as staying at the aldora villa.
Casa Mexicana certainly looks nice from my visits to breakfast there and many here enjoy it. It certainly offers much more than their two cheaper properties. All rooms have balconies, they have a sun deck, etc.
Blue Angel is very nice. I used to stay there before the improvements and associated rate increases, and I am sure it's even nicer now altho I hated that they cemented over the marble animals in the floors. Maybe they'll chip those out someday. It is
not walking distance to much else to me tho. If I want a hiking vacation, I got to a national park and camp for $7/night.
I've stayed there a couple trips, liked it, but my rooms did not have a kitchenette. I think they have some, but mine did not. Only the end room on the second floor has a balcony. I didn't go to the third to look around.
I usually book thru Hotels.com to get the reward points, actually a slightly cheaper rate, and more recourse. For last trip I was promised a kitchenette, didn't get it, but got a nice refund discount. I see that Hotels.com and Casa Mexicana's site for Colonial have been updated, both with corrections. Studio rooms do not have kitchenettes but suites do, and cost more. I saw one claim that it's a block from Casa Mexicana & buffet, but it's actually 3½ blocks. There is still some info showing coffee makers included, but that's not true of the Studios - available in the lobby. I usually take supplies, buy a cheap maker at Mega, and give it to someone when I leave - every trip.
Warning: They claim to have 2 beds in every room, either a double and a single or two doubles, but my rooms only had 1 king bed - possibly because I book as a solo traveler, and that was fine. Had I been traveling with my home dive bud, it would have been a major problem - one we almost had once in Hobox.
I own the Villa Aldora and I vote for Suites Bahia.
Why is that? Casa Mexicana is within his budget, certainly nicer, and with a lot of convenience. I am thinking about going with Bahai next time to get a guaranteed balcony for a lot less than Casa Mex, but I do like Colonial being a block from front street and so quiet.