1. What was your first dive like?
2. How many dives did it take to get comfortable?
3. When did you feel like a "real" diver?
I have been posting on scubaboard pretty much the whole time I've been diving. I have a lot more posts than dives.
I was comfortable the moment I hit my first pool session. I never had any trepidation at all about the whole experience. I've been snorkeling for over 20 years at least a couple times per year average and many of my other leisure activities revolve around the water. I'm also rescue trained (not scuba rescue) and ex military so I'm familiar with "stress" situations and how to deal with panic response.
Some might argue that I'm more comfortable than I should be, given my experiences so far. They might be right but I try to keep that in mind every time I don my gear.
1) My first dive I seriously considered doing solo because I couldn't find a buddy in Kona that wanted to do some shore dives. I ended up finding a shop through recommendations here on SB that did guided shore dives. Somewhere in my post history is an account of that dive but basically it was me and 3 other tourists with the guide. All the other tourists had "lots" of dives (I think the total for the three was somewhere in the low hundreds) and it went very smoothly other than the guide having to tow one of the divers out because he was a bit further in years and clearly a vacation diver (and probably a vacation exerciser). I had "planned the dive" in so much as I paid attention when the guide gave the dive brief and I verified I would be okay with my own eRDP. I have no idea if my buddy did that or not, we didn't really discuss it much. We did discuss some hand signals and I did our buddy checks after being introduced and we more or less followed the guide. I tried to use my compass occasionally but in all honesty that's one of my weaker skills. At the end, the guide suggested if I was going to frog kick a lot I should maybe look at shorter fins and all the other divers didn't believe it was my first dive because my buoyancy was better than theirs. (In their defense I had just finished my training and they had all had a year or more since their previous dives.)
This and the night manta ray dive off of Kona are the only "guided" dives I've ever done. All others have been me and a buddy.
2) I guess just one. In my OW course I'd gotten my partially pulled off, my reg kicked out of my mouth and had a buddy who was on the edge of panic pretty much the whole time. I'd dealt with the "big scary" things I knew about and I'd done it in cold water with low(ish) visibility.
3) I'll let you know if/when I get there. I'm far too novice to consider myself a diver. Hell, I've been rock climbing for almost 18 years and I still don't consider myself "a climber". I'll probably quit doing it if I ever feel like I reach that level of "old hat". I find when people get there they often make careless mistakes that have dire consequences. I'm a newb comfortable with planning and executing dives within my training and a couple pushing the boundaries of my training. I'm taking baby steps in that direction.