Great thread and has been a great read.
As many have pointed out vis is relative and can improve / get worse on any dive.
I have been on stellar wreck dives only to have a cloud drift in from off the wreck.
There are the occasional dirt darts that crash into and around a wreck that blow areas out as well.
Or a crazy SM diver in a cargo hold of silt trying to slip under the main deck!
In the caves vis is usually well over the generally accepted 20-30 feet min. to safely dive them.
However in the event of a silt out, "which can happen.....does happen" you have to be able to remain calm navigate out on the line in no vis.
This is not for everyone but some like myself do not mind so much.
I have trained for these conditions, I continue to train for no vis, and it is what keeps me going in the off season.
When inland waters are all I have I dive them.
If a local lake or quarry it maters not we give them a go.
At training sites in the summer around here it is like diving in pea soup literally!
Buoyancy, proper weighting, are skills few of the cattle trainers care or try to take the time to explain.
If you doubt me then join me for a dive from mid-June to the end of August it can get nasty.
I LOVE IT!
When the training season is in full swing our dives average around 1.5-2 hrs in length we run lines around the quarry with our reels, putting jumps, T's, other navigational arrows and aids.
This is now our playground to train for REAL dives gone bad!
We do this every year and it has become a great skill honing activity.
Who wants to blow the vis for other divers doing a lost line or lost buddy drill?
When it is all ready tore completely up, ''Who Cares?".
These dives have pushed me into places underwater I thought I would never go.
That meaning 3 hours underwater not below 45' , tired, cold, sore, physically ready to out of the water but in low to no vis constantly keeping vigilance on maintaining proper trim and dive protocol.
When I get to do a real Wreck or Cave dive I am anticipating hazards, planning for failures, managing dive stress on the role, keeping my awareness running on MAX!
This doesn't happen by accident it comes from time in the water not just swimming but with some purposeful training.
The few who have dive with me understand where I come from and we have had some incredible dives in total crap vis with the occasional OW diver crashing into us!
It happens and we laugh and move on.
On a REAL dive Wreck / Cave if the vis is totally blown and not a familiar site or with a uncomfortable buddy.....dive gets scrapped for another day.
If we are familiar and everyone is on board we dive.
That being said dive plans and objectives can be altered to fit the conditions to remain in safe guidelines.
If you train for it, dive in it, vis like other conditions can be managed.
CamG