Diver rescued after drifting 16 hours near Bali

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Thanks Quero and Wisnu. Google translate tells a similar story but not a clear one. :eek:

So do either of you carry Personal Locator Beacons that can connect by satellite to advise authorities of emergency need and location, with local tracking, like the ACR 2881 I mentioned above - or have considered carrying? I left mine in the dive canister all week, hung it from my life vest on the boat, then transferred it to my BC for dives - as I've read too many stories of surfacing divers swept away and boats sinking even in Cozumel Mexico waters.

There was a local instructor, American Expat, on the boat who told of his 4 hour float there once, but he still doesn't carry anything! His boat has a beacon, but he doesn't carry any signaling devices or PLBs. :silly:

It would be difficult for me to determine who to shoot first, the S**T for brains dive master/instructor or the S**T for brain dive operator.

Both should be banned from the profession
I missed the part that said it was their fault? Currents happen. What do you carry when you dive off of Oar--eee---gun?
 
Don I own two Nautilus Lifeline units, and I rent them to my customers who want them, but I have never personally carried one with me. Since I bought them I haven't dived at any super high-current areas where I would risk being swept away. Next time I go dive at any sites of the Indonesian Throughflow, though, I will certainly carry them with me (one for me, one for my buddy).
 
Don I own two Nautilus Lifeline units, and I rent them to my customers who want them, but I have never personally carried one with me. Since I bought them I haven't dived at any super high-current areas where I would risk being swept away. Next time I go dive at any sites of the Indonesian Throughflow, though, I will certainly carry them with me (one for me, one for my buddy).
The Nautilus is also a good choice, a better choice for marine use only probably - smaller & cheaper than my PLB & Canister combined. Looks like $300 her in the US. Looks like a good gadget for you to carry on local dives too.

I went with the $200 PLB more for inland risks as I mentioned. At $40/year, I have to wonder why they're not more common with hikers, climbers, inland boaters, hunters - all outdoors adventurers. Outdoor Equipment Rentals furnished the canister for my last trip, and they rent the PLBs too.
 
Don I own two Nautilus Lifeline units, and I rent them to my customers who want them, but I have never personally carried one with me. Since I bought them I haven't dived at any super high-current areas where I would risk being swept away. Next time I go dive at any sites of the Indonesian Throughflow, though, I will certainly carry them with me (one for me, one for my buddy).

Do you know if these are a good investment outside of North America and the Caribbean? I'm not certain the authorities here would respond to one of these systems.

I carry an affordable small strobe on all my dives. It's handy for a lot of underwater marking opportunities, doesn't take up much space in a side pocket, and can be seen from very far away (especially from search aircraft).
 
Do you know if these are a good investment outside of North America and the Caribbean? I'm not certain the authorities here would respond to one of these systems.

I carry an affordable small strobe on all my dives. It's handy for a lot of underwater marking opportunities, doesn't take up much space in a side pocket, and can be seen from very far away (especially from search aircraft).
A good number of local vessels have no GPS, but dive boats typically do, so any boat with a GPS receiver can receive the coordinates transmitted by the device and head to that point for a rescue. Furthermore, the device has a voice radio, so even if a boat doesn't have a GPS, a call can be made on the international emergency frequency and a boat can be on the visual lookout for the victim. The biggest problem with the Nautilus Lifeline that I have found is registering an MMSI. Here in Thailand only actual vessels are able to do this, so I had to provide a US-based address in order to register the device so that the transmission capability could be enabled. I've been told that if a victim uses the Lifeline without a valid local registration of the MMSI there could be a fine imposed for illegal use of the airwaves, but who cares? I'll pay the fine and be happy to be rescued and safe and sound!
 
I have both a Nautilis lifeline as well as a PLB in a waterproof container. I have more faith in the PLB as it contacts Australian authorities regardless of where I am in the world. The Lifeline is only good for about 20km but the PLB works anywhere.

Been left behind hence the duplicated gear. Its not a nice feeling at all.

Bali is bad for people being in the water for long periods. When we were there at last xmas, we were told about people who drifted from one of the Islands to past Sanur and on their way to Australia when a local boat saw them. It happens more than we realise. I would recommend people take steps to ensure they can be rescued from circumstances like this. To think the LDS will not put you into this sort of a situation is living in dreamland. Just because you live in a first world country doesn't mean you wont get left behind or lost.

I take a PLB, nautilus radio (no issue with licencing to a diver, just tell them), mirror, strobe, light, diver alert.

I don't consider this excessive, how much is my life worth?
 


A ScubaBoard Staff Message...

This post has been merged with an existing thread on the topic. Marg, SB Senior Moderator


Victims:
- Havis : Indonesian instructor with over 15 years experience diving in Gili
- Julie : French diver Advanced and CMAS** with nearly 100 dives

Dive site : Halik - Lombok - - Indonesia Northern Gili Trawangan Island

Problem: Both divers are caught in a very unusual and powerful undercurrent and after a quick decision of the instructor to resurface (11 minutes immersion) it is already too late and the two divers began a long drift that will end in Bali (about 80km as the crow flies) .

Sequence of events:
Havis and Julie went for a dive on the site Halik. Immersion was done at 11am for a planned return to 11:45 max noon.
The crew on the boat waiting for the divers return to the surface until 12:15 (15 minutes after maximum expected return) before starting the research procedures.

The boat Scuba Froggy supported by the boat Buddha Dive went in search of the missing divers towards the sea in the direction of currents.

At 12:30 after no sign of life divers alert is sent to all boats on site (6 that day), the majority of diving clubs on the three Gili and a Search and Rescue service in the islands. A total of 6 different diving clubs boats (Blue Marlin, Dream Divers, dive 3W, Lombok Dive, Dolphin Dive, Buddha Dive) and two small fast boat begin a coordinated research on a larger scale. Other structures not mentioned are certainly involved in this research without identifying themselves and we thank them.

At 14h and after having found nothing Scuba Froggy orders a helicopter to come and search the area to a large radius. The helicopter arrived from Bali to Gili Trawangan at 15h. From 15h to 17h helicopter of a private company surveyed the sky towards the south west to 30km wide and changed course to the north east more than 40km from the coast in vain (south west and north east being major currents off the Gili islands).

18h end of the day search supported by vessels of other companies as well as private.

20h launching a night boat search from Lombok SAR (Search And Rescue Lombok ) team to patrol the entire area south of Lombok and this throughout the night .

In the meantime 12:30 - 20h all fishermen Bali and Lombok are alerted of the disappearance of two divers, all Fast Boat companies making the link between Bali and Lombok are cautioned that forward half - speed and look for these divers at that time all the areas in South , South West, North and North East are covered area of South Bali and all three Gili islands (Trawangan, Meno and Air) by an armada of fishing boat, fast boat, private and commercial structures.

At nightfall Scuba Froggy in coordination with the SAR team , the general of the Air Force and the General of Navy Lombok, managers of some diving structures of Lombok as well as members of the instructor family the research for the coming day are organized with a helicopter flight over the north , an ultralight plane from the Air Force in flight over the southern area with two pilots can fly all day , the same armada of boat, a small fast boat off Gili Trawangan northbound , a dive boat heading north along the coast , a small fast boat and a dive boat heading south the first remote coasts and the second nearby coasts and finally three boats from three different dive center in Bali present on the southern part of the island .

8am a call is received informing that the divers disappeared the day before were found by a Balinese fisherman and they are safe, tired but in good mental and physical health.
Repatriation of Lombok was made ​​by a fast boat at 14h and their arrival was acclaimed by a crowd of rescue workers and family members.

In total they will drift more than 20 hours and a team of more than a hundred people were mobilized to find them.

Our greatest satisfaction is that after all the efforts made ​​and resources put into works quickly and coordinated we allowed these people to find their family.

No wrong with the instructor who made ​​the right decisions at the right time on a site that he knew perfectly.
No wrong with the ship's crew which wasn’t suspecting any strong undercurrent of a well-known and regularly dived site.

We want in the name of Scuba Froggy to thank all those who have mobilized and responded present to the rescue ( Blue Marlin , Dream Divers , Dolphin Dive School, Dive Buddha , Lombok Dive, Dive 3W , the SAR team , general the air Force and navy Lombok, Bali air , all fishermen present companies fast boat connection between Bali and Lombok , private as Kus , Erwin , Onk , and many others even as the list goes on) and helped by their moral and material support to find and save the lives of these two divers .

Also thank you to all the Scuba Froggy team for his full involvement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We were out off some islands from Pedang Bai and the current got us and pulled us behind the island. I set off my diver alert and although the boat guy over the other side did not hear it (we were some 500m away from the island), another boat did and alerted him and he came around and found us. A small item that was well worth the money. The plastic whistles we are supposed to have are a joke. Useless and soon as they are wet at all its like blowing into a wet straw and hoping to play the national anthem.

I always go with my PLB and I advise the Australian search and rescue branch via web site where I am and what I am doing on my holiday. If they get the call (and it went off once and works well), they can scan my file and see where I am diving (general area) and thus contact the local authorities. However if you are in places like Fiji, and its the weekend, forget it, as the navy doesn't operate on weekends.
 
Here I go again being a broken record with this same message. I have been posting this since 2009. IF YOU DIVE IN THE OCEAN BUY AND CARRY A PLB,

http://www.scubaboard.com/forums/near-misses-lessons-learned/287782-lost-sea.html

Any diver whom dives offshore should be equipped with a PLB. It should be manditory. Blame whomever you want but the bottomline is your the one that is lost and your the one that might die as a result.

A Nautilus is fine if your diving in a area that has alot of modern recreational boat traffic (like off the coast of Ft Lauderdale, Florida) but I would not trust my life to it. The transmit distance is going to be limited and it depends upon someone else having the right equipment and be actively monitoring that equipment. It is better then nothing but not as good as having a full feature PLB.

If you have a PLB tell the dive operation and give them the contact number for the regional EPIRB/PLB response center. If you go missing you can trigger the PLB and the dive operation could have been in touch with the response center whom will immediately have you location coordinates once the PLB is triggered and provide those coordinates to the dive boat so that you can be picked up in short order with minimal fuss and expense. This is the same response center the monitors 24x7 for Commercial and Recreational Ship EPIRBS around the world.

I continue to be mystified why Dive Cert agencies, Dive Instructors, Dive Operations and DIVERS themselves continue to ignore the fact that anything unpredicted and unexpected can happen at anytime on the open ocean that can and does result in many people being lost at sea and in many cases never found. It is not a rare occurence.

John
 

Back
Top Bottom