There was fancier place that was about a 25 min. ride inland. I'll try and find the name of it for you. It was more expensive, but very good food.
Landhuis Daniel?
Landhuis Daniel Restaurant, Curacao Restaurants :: Caribbean Edge
Interested in car rental suggestions and dining off site.
If you're going to drive to town one day to shop, I second the Ribs Factory for dinner. But it's sort of east of downtown so probably an hour back to KH from there.
There's some options in Piscadera Bay, Hooks Hut - just what it sounds like, a combo bar/outdoor restaurant/diveshop, good reasonable food, great views. Sand underfoot kind of place. I think they have a band some nights.
The Marriott has a really nice oceanfront restaurant. It's the one past the pool complex. We had a table 20' from the water, the food was Marriott quality and it was a nice calm night so they lit the torches and everyone dined by moonlight. It's a really nice Marriott. Small casino on-site also. I also ate one night at the better Hilton restaurant next door, it was fine but they have no view.
But plan on 20-30 mins. driving minimum between Piscadera Bay and West Punt.
Closer to you, Habitat's restaurant is good for lunch if you're diving there. I wasn't as impressed with the Sunset Waters restaurant. Both are high on the hill which is good since there's no A/C. Not worth going to unless you're diving there though as it's a 10-15 min. drive in from the main road to either place.
Going farther east along the coast into Willemsted, we had big lobsters at the SurfnTurf, a small local place adjacent to the Dive Bus hut. If you're going to do some shore diving with them, it's a good place to eat afterwards.
Real casual dining but not inexpensive. I think they might've gone and got our lobster out of a pen on the reef after we ordered.
We stayed in Lagun for several days, about 10-15mins. east of West Punt. For dinner we mostly wound up driving to Willemsted, there's not a lot of options once you get farther west.
One other thing to mention, I'm not sure if Kura Hulanda has a small store but if not, there's not a lot of options in the area to buy packaged food/drinks. There is a small market (West?) of Wilbrordus on the ocean road but she didn't have much.
If you're arriving in the afternoon, you might want to consider stopping at Centrum Market in Piscadera before you drive out to the Lodge. It's about 2 miles or so south of the rotary where you turn off to go to West Punt. Instead of going right there, go straight through (south) and Centrum will be about 2-3 stoplights down on your right. Big sign, it's on the SW corner. They even sell cheap styro containers so you can keep a few things cold on the drive out.
hth,