Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Yikes! I just re-read the original post "Help Me Get Bp/w for Smaller Wife" and realized that you're NOT trying to trade your Smaller Wife for a BP/ Wing.... I feel better now.
I knew it sounded awkward when I wrote it but I don’t have the correct terminology.having never dove from a boat I'm not sure what you mean about slots for tanks? I do understand about pinch flats.
Just in case anyone is following or does so in the future, here's the sizes of each small bp
Halcyon - 14" x 9.25"
Oxycheq - 13.1" x 10.25"
Deep Sea Supply - 13.125" x ??? (but I don't think the width is as important)
With that said, if I did get a small bp, what would be the optimal wing? As @Ayisha pointed out, I don't want her to be in a small bp/ and the wing be some monster?
Understood, which is why DSS plate is still in the running. If i did go that route and picked up 2 setups, what size wings should I get? I dont know the difference between the Taurus or the LCD. I would "think" 35lb would be good for me, 30lb would be good for her.
The size of the wing should be based on your rig, not the size of the person, within reason. A 40 lb wing is for doubles. The standard size wing for a single tank is up to 25 - 30 lbs, even for larger people. So a 25 - 30 lb wing would be suitable for both of you, like the DSS LCD 30. She would have a small bp and you would probably have the regular bp if you're of fairly average size.
It's too bad that the DSS doesn't come in Aluminum. It's great for travelling as it's lighter, and ensures your wife won't be overweighted depending on where you dive (warm/cold/salt/fresh water), the type of exposure protection (none, shorty, full, thickness) she wears, and the type of tanks (AL, HP, LP, composite) she uses.